Plan Driven verses Agile Approach

Statistics vs. Heuristics.

A quite number of project leaders trust software development is a statistically controllable process; others may not. Their subsequent strategies are incompatible. This is one of the places where friction arises between agile and plan-driven project leaders.

Individuals and Interactions vs. Processes and Tools.

Some leaders believe that with the right process, they can become immune to the turnover of key people. Others believe that no process can offer that immunity; the heart of good software development will always reside in the individual people on the project. As with the statistical approach, we are more likely to find process-centric leaders running plan-driven projects, and individual centric leaders running agile projects.

Responding to Change vs. Following a Plan.

It is a fundamental difference between the two project types whether the team is encouraged to or penalized for responding to changes. Even though business needs, requirements, technologies, and people are constantly moving these days, some projects are still fixed in some combination of time, scope, and cost, and must operate in the plan-driven range.

Project Plan as MFI or MFF.

If the requirements or technologies are likely to change late in the game or without notice, or the team does not have experience with the technology, then it is a poor strategy to treat the project plan as a MFI issue. In those situations, the agile leader's attitude that the plan is a MFF proposition works better. The leader allocates energy to re-planning coarsely but frequently.

Design as MFI or MFF.

A plan-driven project team, believing that the design can be worked out in advance (MFI), expends resources early to gain that information and lock down the design. For those design elements that cannot be foreseen (MFF issues), plan-oriented design teams often design the system so that a range of future design constraints can be easily incorporated - expending extra design energy early in anticipation of having a more adaptable design.

Many agile designers find those resulting designs overly complicated. Agreeing that certain issues are MFF issues, they argue that a better MFF strategy is to make a simpler design in the first place, with less built-in flexibility. The saved money can then be allocated to change the design on an as-needed basis.

Some agile designers argue that the MFI component of the design activity is negligibly small, thus little or no effort should be expended on anticipated design changes.

Serial vs. Concurrent Development.

There is a fundamental difference in the strategies applied when agility is a priority compared with when cost is the priority. As Principle No. 8 describes, cost-sensitive projects do better with serial development when that can be successfully executed. Unfortunately, there are so many surprises in projects that it is very difficult to execute successfully.

Working Software vs. Comprehensive Documentation.

One tends to find more initiatives for comprehensive documentation on statistics-, process- and plan-driven projects, but this is not intrinsic. Many experienced managers use prototypes, simulators, and incremental development to reduce risk and gain early information on both agile and plan-driven projects, feeding that information into the plan as quickly as possible.

Customer Collaboration vs. Contract Negotiation.

Plan-driven project leaders clearly can improve their situation by increasing the collaboration in their customer relations, even if they must write and enforce contracts. This is a case in which plan-driven project leaders can employ some of the same work practices as agile project leaders.

Project Plan and Design on Cost-sensitive Projects.

A detailed plan does not, by itself, confer cost savings or safety to a project. Detailed plans and detailed designs enable an estimable base-line cost. The manager can then tell if the cost is going up or down over time. It is not the detail of the plan, but successful application of MFF and MFI decisions that makes the difference in the result.

 


Advertisements

Agile Burndown Chart Agile Change Management Agile Data Warehousing
Agile Extreme programming Agile Feature Driven development Agile Fixed Price Contract
Agile Joint application development Agile lean software development Agile software engineer
Agile software engineering Agile Test Driven Development Agile Tools Technologies
Benefits of agile development Agile Crystal Methods Agile Dynamic Systems Development
Benefits of agile development Plan_Driven_verses_Agile_Approach Agile Dynamic Systems Development

Certification

PMP »
Six Sigma »
CBAP »

Mathematics

LKG Mathematics »
UKG Mathematics »
Grade 1 Mathematics »
Grade 2 Mathematics »
Grade 3 Mathematics »
Grade 4 Mathematics »
Grade 5 Mathematics »

English

LKG English »
UKG English »
Grade 1 English »
Grade 2 English »
Grade 3 English »
Grade 4 English »
Grade 5 English »

Competitive Examination

ACT »
ISEE Upper Level »
GED »
GMAT »
OAT »
STAT »
ASVAB »
MAT »
CLAT »
GAT »
PSATNMSQT »

Aptitude

Average »
Banker Discount »
Boat »
Calendar »
Chain Rule »
Compound Interest »
Data Sufficiency »
Decimal »
HCF and LCM »
Mixture »
Number »
Partnership »
Percentage »
Permutation and Combination »
Pipes and Cistern »
Probability »
Profit and Loss »
Race n Game »
Ratio »
Simple Interest »
Simplification »
Square Root n Cube Root »
Stock »
Time and Work »
Volume and Surface Area »
Train »

GK

Science »
Geography »
History »

Tutorial

HTML5 Tutorial »
cloud computing Tutorial »
Agile Tutorial »

Miscellaneous

Business Ideas »
Company Career List »
Whats up »

Agile Tutorial

Agile Feature Driven development »
Agile Joint application development »
Agile lean software development »
Agile Management Technique »
Agile methodology »
Agile project management »
Agile scrum »
Agile Software design »
Agile Software development »
Agile software engineer »
Agile software engineering »
Agile Test Driven Development »
Agile Tools Technologies »
Benefits of agile development »
Agile Crystal Methods »
Agile Dynamic Systems Development »


Advertisements

Agile Tutorial Advance

Agile Change Management »
Agile Data Warehousing »
Agile Fixed Price Contract »
Agile marketing »
Plan_Driven_verses_Agile_Approach »
Agile Extreme programming »


Examination

1000 QnA ways for Child Manners and Etiquette »
Practice online 10 sets: ACT Examination »
Practice online 15 sets: STAT Examination »
Practice online 15 sets: SAT Examination »
Practice online 15 sets: PSAT Examination »
Practice online 15 sets: OAT Examination »
Practice online 15 sets: MAT Examination »
Practice online 15 sets: ISEE Upper Examination »
Practice online 15 sets: GMAT Examination »
Practice online 15 sets: GED Examination »
Practice online 15 sets: GAT Examination »
Practice online 15 sets: CLAT Examination »
Practice online 15 sets: ASVAB Examination »


Advertisements

Examination

Practice 3000 PMP Online Question »
Practice 1000+ LKG Grade Mathematics Question »
Practice 1000+ LKG Grade English Question »
Practice 1000+ UKG Grade Mathematics Question »
Practice 1000+ UKG Grade English Question »
Practice 1000+ 1st Grade Mathematics Question »
Practice 1000+ 1st Grade English Question »
Practice 1000+ 2nd Grade Mathematics Question »
Practice 1000+ 2nd Grade English Question »
Practice 1000+ 3rd Grade Mathematics Question »
Practice 1000+ 3rd Grade English Question »
Practice 1000+ 4th Grade Mathematics Question »
Practice 1000+ 4th Grade English Question »
Practice 1000+ 5th Grade Mathematics Question »
Practice 1000+ 5th Grade English Question »


#